Category

  • Applying to College
  • Choosing a College
  • College
  • College Admissions
  • College Admissions Advising
  • College Search

Issue

  • Fall 2026

My office phone rang the morning after Wellesley College’s early decision (ED) results were released. At the time, I was a class dean at the college.

A father called, all the way from China, thrilled that his daughter* had been admitted. After congratulating him, I asked if he had any questions.

He asked about our engineering majors.

Wellesley College is a small liberal arts college with no engineering majors.

I told him this and asked why his daughter had applied ED to Wellesley.

He said, “Really? Oh, well, she applied because it has a beautiful lake.”

That was an extreme case, but it vividly illustrated something I learned in subtler ways every day: our understanding of college fit is often incomplete.

The View from Inside

As independent educational consultants, our work is necessarily focused on admissions. We get to know our students well. We support them through one of the most stressful seasons of their lives.

And then, even when we stay in touch, we are not there.

I spent more than 30 years on the other side of that goodbye—as a professor, academic advisor, and dean at Wellesley College and later at Tufts University. I supported students through both successes and challenges. The challenges were real: academic struggle, mental health crises, disciplinary proceedings, academic probation, major changes, transfers, and leaves of absence. So were the successes: studying abroad, pursuing co-ops and internships, securing peer leadership positions, and, ultimately, graduation. When students arrived on campus, I encouraged them to “dream big!” Over time, I helped them prioritize among their many goals. I still keep in touch with many of my students. I recently visited one I hadn’t seen in 21 years at the cookie business she now owns.

I also developed programs, pathways, and opportunities, including double-degree programs with MIT and Olin College of Engineering, designed to help students grow. That work, alongside the individual advising, changed how I understand college fit.

What 30 Years Taught Me

The insight I return to most is simple to say and difficult to fully absorb: Students don’t simply attend colleges. They interact with them.

And those interactions—between a particular student and a particular environment—determine far more about a student’s trajectory than the college’s name, ranking, reputation, or even the opportunities it offers.

I watched this play out so many times. I once stood on the sidelines of a field hockey game in my town and talked with a father whose daughter had been recruited to play at Brown University. She later transferred to Quinnipiac University, where she graduated. He was still indignant when he told me, “Do you know what some dean at Brown said to my daughter? ‘How will you change the world?’ What kind of dean says that to a student?”

I said, “A dean at Brown.”

It was a mismatch between a student and an environment.

I also worked with a Wellesley sophomore who came to my office in tears, still unable to get a seat in her first computer science course after three semesters of trying. The major was oversubscribed, and the waitlists were routinely over 100 students long. That meant she couldn’t satisfy the prerequisites to study abroad, which had been one of her dreams. Her goals and the environment were at odds in ways no amount of individual effort could overcome.

In all my years supporting students, I could always tell a first-year student from a senior simply by the way they walked into my office. That difference—confidence, direction, the sense that they were the authors of their own experience—is what I mean by agency.

I hadn’t always recognized it for what it was. When I arrived at Wellesley in 1996, I expected to find fiercely independent women. Instead, I was struck by what I initially read as neediness: a high-touch environment, students who constantly sought guidance and connection. I had come from research universities and didn’t yet understand what a liberal arts college could do.

The year before I arrived, The New York Times had run an article titled “How to Succeed? Go to Wellesley.” Not “how to succeed as a woman.” Just how to succeed. It reported that the college produced women executives far out of proportion to its size. I didn’t know how to reconcile the two.

Then I began to understand: what I had interpreted as neediness wasn’t neediness at all. It was students who knew exactly how to ask for what they needed and how to get it.

That is agency in practice.

The students who flourished had built it through their experiences and relationships in college. They sought out mentors and built those relationships over time. They pursued opportunities, sometimes before they felt fully ready. They understood that college was not something that happened to them—it was something they were building.

Agency is not something students possess or don’t. It develops—through the right environments, the right relationships, and the right kinds of support. Some students arrived at Wellesley or Tufts with very little of it and left with a great deal. Others arrived with apparent confidence and preparation and struggled in environments that did not meet them where they were developmentally.

Emma, a Wellesley first-year, took my introductory computer science (CS) course for non-majors to fulfill a distribution requirement. She loved it. She went on to declare a CS major, and I became her advisor. She earned a PhD at Cornell University and is now a tenured CS professor. When I congratulated her on tenure, she wrote, “It all started with you in CS110.” I have read that sentence many times.

What I Had to Learn Myself

At Johns Hopkins University, where I was an undergraduate, I originally planned to study computer science within the electrical engineering and computer science department. When the department split and students were given the choice to stay or move to computer science, I stayed.

I was influenced by my favorite first-year professor, a CS faculty member, who announced at the end of his final lecture that he was leaving for Smith College—as I heard it at the time, because he wanted to go somewhere that valued undergraduate teaching. If he was leaving, what did that mean for the department? I didn’t ask anyone. I just stayed in electrical engineering.

In my final semester, I discovered I loved earth science when I took History of the Earth and Its Biota as my last science elective, earning an A+. That summer, back home in New York, I opened a letter from my professor containing a membership to the American Museum of Natural History. I had also landed a research position at Columbia University’s Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, applying signal processing techniques to seismic data. It was riveting. But I had already committed to graduate school to study control systems. I thought it was too late to pursue a different direction. I didn’t ask anyone whether it was.

I thought my path was fixed. I didn’t understand that I had the power to shape my own future until much later—until I learned my non-tenure-track faculty position would no longer be supported, and my sister-in-law said to me, “Look what you created for yourself for 14 years. You’ll create something else.”

That changed me.

It is also why I now counsel students the way I do. I tell students they have extraordinary power to create their college experience and their future beyond it.

What This Means for How We Counsel

I have come to see the college search as just one step in a longer journey—one that continues through college and beyond. Our work is to help a student find an environment where they are likely to have the experiences research shows matter most.

The 2014 Gallup-Purdue Index study, which surveyed nearly 30,000 college graduates, found that six experiences were most strongly linked to long-term well-being and professional engagement: a professor who cared about them as a person, a professor who made them excited about learning, a mentor who encouraged their goals, a long-term project, an applied internship or work experience related to their studies, and deep engagement with extracurricular activities. Graduates who had all six were dramatically more likely to be thriving in their lives and work—regardless of where they attended college.

George Kuh’s decades of research on student engagement, including his work with the National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE), reaches similar conclusions: undergraduate research, study abroad, learning communities, capstone experiences, and internships are among those associated with student success.

These findings align with what I have observed across more than 30 years.

An institution can offer all of these experiences. But can a particular student realistically access them? Is the environment one in which the student can develop the agency to pursue them? The answers to those questions determine outcomes.

The Gallup-Purdue study also found that only 3 percent of college graduates had all six experiences. The vast majority of students—at institutions of every kind, including the most prestigious—left college without the experiences most linked to thriving.

That is the gap our profession is positioned to address.

During my time at Wellesley, four students transferred out and later returned. One had gone to a large research university, where she struggled. Without the advising she needed, she took advanced courses she wasn’t prepared for. We required her to stay another semester and earn passing grades before she could return. When she did, she told me she had underestimated what the liberal arts experience at Wellesley had given her.

Students often don’t understand what an environment has given them until they are outside it. And they don’t always know what they need and what to look for until someone helps them see it.

Who cares if a student gets into a prestigious college if they don’t graduate? If they don’t thrive? If it doesn’t lay the foundation for good options after college?

A Larger Question

I call this perspective Deep-Fit—the idea that college fit goes deeper than the characteristics typically considered. It considers how a particular student is likely to interact with a particular environment, and what that environment is likely to do for their development over four years and beyond. It can begin in high school, through the college counseling process itself, where students can learn to understand what they need and find the confidence to pursue it.

Behind that name is a question for us to raise as a profession: What are we trying to accomplish when we talk about college fit?

If the answer is simply admission, our work ends when the student chooses their college. If it is something larger—and I believe it is—then we are not just helping students gain admission. We are helping them understand who they are, what they need and value, and where they are likely to thrive—and then empowering them to go after it. That is a much bigger charge.

I have been sitting with that question for over 30 years. I think it’s one worth asking together.

By Jennifer Stephan, PhD, IECA (MA), Lantern College Counseling

*Some student details have been changed to protect privacy.

Note: ChatGPT and Claude were used to assist with drafting and editing. All ideas, experiences, and conclusions are the author’s own.

Category

  • Applying to College
  • Choosing a College
  • College
  • College Admissions
  • College Admissions Advising
  • College Search

Issue

  • Fall 2026